The current crisis of young people not in education, employment and training, is unacceptable. Alan Milburn’s long-awaited final report, From a Welfare State to a Working State, does not shy away from the scale of the challenge, and it sets an ambitious goal: to cut the NEET rate to around five per cent by 2036.
Businesses want to give young people their first chance. But the test for Chambers of Commerce, and the 50,000 businesses we represent, is a simple one: will these proposals make it easier, cheaper and less risky to take them on? Here is our early take on what to welcome, where business still needs government to go further, and what must happen next.
What we can welcome
Much of what Milburn proposes reflects what businesses have been telling us.
BCC data shows that 73% of employers are struggling with the cost of labour, and the Milburn report acknowledges these cost pressures. We welcome the proposed reduction in employer National Insurance contributions (NICs) for 21- to 24-year-olds, the maintenance of the differential between youth and adult rates of the National Living Wage, and additional financial help for taking on and retaining young people. The proposed extension of the Jobs Guarantee will also reduce the cost and risk of taking on young people who are further from the labour market.
Government should also make better use of the funding that already exists to train young people. We have long called for an end to the Treasury top-slice of the Growth and Skills Levy which employers pay into, but doesn’t get fully allocated to skills. Ringfencing the full receipts to the apprenticeship budget will unlock up to £1bn a year to fund vital routes into work. This is something that Milburn has recommend the government do to demonstrate their ambition in this space.
Employers are also concerned about what happens to young people in education before they reach the workplace. Prevention and early intervention throughout school and college is essential to stop young people falling out of the system and give them the skills they need to be work ready. Our research shows 73% of employers most want young people to focus on communication skills, while 67% prioritised confidence and resilience. This should be helped by renewed efforts to boost work experience opportunities, as well as the recommendation for Ofsted to measure work readiness.
Finally, we know that lack of capacity in further education is creating a bottleneck of opportunity in many communities, where demand for training is far outstripping supply. Extra investment is badly needed and Chambers across England will welcome an increase to FE funding.
Where we still need to push as a business community
Milburn has proposed a relief on employer NICs by doubling the earnings threshold from £5,000 to £10,000 for 21–24-year-olds. The proposed relief starts with retail and hospitality and is to be phased in ‘as fiscal conditions allow’. But retail and hospitality are not the only sectors that offer young people their first opportunity, and sectors across the economy are still struggling to absorb the damaging effects of the April 2025 NICs increase. Government cannot push this recommendation into the long grass and should set out a clear path to extend relief to every sector, so there is a pathway for every young person no matter what sector their chosen career path is in.
We also need government to heed Milburn’s warning about the detrimental impact of changes in the Employment Rights Act, particularly on zero-hours contracts. Young people account for 50% of workers whose main contract is zero-hours, because of the flexibility it allows to fit seasonal or temporary work around education and life commitments. The Employment Rights Act is restricting how businesses can use these contracts, and Milburn rightly identifies that this will directly impact opportunities for young people. The reforms need to be reconsidered to ensure they target exploitative practices rather than reduce opportunity.
Furthermore, while ringfencing the Growth and Skills Levy for training will boost opportunities, restrictions to apprenticeship funding based on age are not the right approach to drive growth. Helping more young people start apprenticeships should not come at the expense of older workers who need to retrain and develop new skills. Businesses face skills shortages at every level. Making firms pay more to train over 25s will simply discourage investment in them, in turn reducing the number of opportunities for young people on the next step of the career ladder as older workers progress more slowly.
Finally, Milburn proposes a disability employment quota which would be voluntary at first, helping to focus minds of companies who are able to do more to take on people with disabilities. However, the 2025 Keep Britain Working Review showed employers need a lot of support to be confident and capable in supporting disabled people in work, and such a commitment should not become mandatory.
The business test: is the average SME more likely to take on a young person?
There is a simple test that we can use to predict the success of the changes proposed today: does any of this make it easier, cheaper, and less risky to take on a young person? To answer this question, BCC’s Insights Unit built a cost stack calculator to analyse government policy changes and their impact at a firm level. The calculator revealed that the average SME has seen domestic policy costs rise 70% in the last 10 years.
Unfortunately, the headline measure to reduce employer National Insurance contributions won’t do enough to bring down this cost stack. Our initial analysis shows no change in costs (£0) for a 50-person firm with £5m turnover outside retail and hospitality. For the same firm within the retail and hospitality sector, the NICs change would relieve up to £750 per 21 to 24 year-old worker if it goes ahead.
Additional incentives announced by Milburn could alleviate some of the cost pressures on hiring, such as an extra £500 for SMEs taking on an apprentice, on top of existing grants, and maintaining the differential between adult and youth minimum wage rates. But while that may reduce the cost base slightly, there are more cost pressures coming through further increases in the National Living Wage, and new requirements from the Employment Rights Act. In short, the Milburn review’s recommendations will help but there is more to be done to turn the tide on cost that is so crucial to unlocking demand for young people. Urgent action by Government is needed, as the BCC called for in its recent budget submission.
What’s next?
Our analysis suggests there is no room for a half-hearted response if we are going to shift the dial. Government now has to turn this report into a reality. A Youth Opportunities Unit reporting to the Prime Minister and a white paper setting out detailed action are due early next year, alongside work with the devolved governments to ensure the benefits are felt across the UK.
The Secretary of State for Work and Pensions, Pat McFadden, has suggested the government will accept recommendations on welfare, the youth guarantee and local delivery. But so far there is no official mention of where the money is coming from, any movement on zero-hours contracts, or on confirming the glide path to NICs reduction, despite the Prime Minister conceding that there is a balance to be struck on employment rights legislation. Those are the issues that will decide whether a small business takes a chance on a young person and ultimately whether Milburn’s review will make a difference.
Businesses are ready to play their part, and Chambers stand ready to help deliver at the local level, for example through Local Skills Improvement Plans. But government needs to meet business halfway through lower costs, a sensible approach to employment regulation, and young people who arrive ready to work. We will be pressing for all three as the government’s response takes shape.